On September 27th, Shelburne Orchard hosted its 7th annual Pie Fest. M and I entered two pies. Well I made both but he supervised. LOL We had been testing pies for over 4 weeks in preparation for the big day.
McIntosh, Pippin, Wolf, Paula Red....the list of apples goes on and on. My dining room table was covered in apples. I tried several kinds of crusts - All butter, butter and Crisco, butter and lard, butter and cream cheese.....butter butter butter.... The fillings were basic as the contest was a classic apple pie contest. M kept wanting to get fancy and I think ultimately wore himself out. For a man who does not like apples, he sure put away alot of apple pie. The ultimate compliment I think and I thank him for his tenacity.
I had a couple of meltdowns. Crust was not pretty enough...pie exhaustion. But we finished at 4am the day of the contest. Before I reveal the pics....here are my top tips.
- All butter is the way to go - though it is the most difficult crust to deal with
- Lattice tops DO count as double crust entries - we were not sure.
- Lattice tops can hide alot of flaws
- Pyrex glass pie pans are the best - they allow for the crust to brown on the bottom
- I loved Pippin apples - firm and tasty - no falling apart in the pie
- Put sugar in your crust - no question just do it.
- Half and half wash over egg wash
- Murray River salt is awesome!
Now the pictures.....
My pie - Classic Apple Pie
M's "Pie"
The Competition
The Mother of All Pies
So the real question - did we win? Sadly...no. But I know my pie was up there with the best. The judges came back a few times to retaste my pie. I need to work on my appearance...needs to be fancier. I will post the recipes later this week.
But I am now sick of apple pie. I keep finding dough all over my kitchen and I still have a whole bowl of apples left.
Happy Autumn!